“a core goal of public policy should be to facilitate the development of institutions that bring out the best in humans.”
Elinor Ostrom, Nobel Prize lecture, 2009, pp. 434-435.
🖨️📋🤝
Elinor Ostrom (1933-2012) was a political scientist and the first woman to receive the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences.
She shared the 2009 prize for work on economic governance, especially the commons. In her prize lecture she describes how she and her colleagues compared the ways people managed fisheries and irrigation systems. They looked at the rules people actually used, including who could draw on a resource and how a community could tell whether the rules were being followed (Indiana University Ostrom Workshop, n.d.; Ostrom, 2009).
Among the features Ostrom identified in enduring arrangements was a way for people affected by rules to help revise them. The details varied with the resource and the community. The fictional print room below has a modest problem by comparison: too little time on one copier. It raises a related question about who can change an arrangement once the person who used to settle things leaves.
The Room Reopened on Thursday
On the fourth Thursday after Marta moved away, Noor slid a fresh stack of paper into the copier and put the booking sheet on its clipboard. Before she left, Marta had taped a diagram inside the cabinet showing which tray took the heavier paper. It saved Noor from feeding a set of postcards through the wrong slot. The toner order had gone through with the part number Marta left in the binder. For the first three Thursdays these were the details Noor had worried about getting right.
The print room occupied a former coatroom in the neighborhood hall. For two hours on Thursdays, anyone could bring a file and print a small job for the price of the paper. Noor had worked alongside Marta long enough to know the equipment and what could reasonably fit into fifteen minutes. Since taking charge, she had asked everyone to book a slot. The plain sheet on the hall noticeboard gave people a time they could plan around. It also gave the evening volunteer a reasonable chance of clearing the paper scraps and locking up by eight.
Celia arrived at twenty past seven in the dark trousers she wore in the hospital kitchen. She had a flyer for a tenants' meeting on her phone and wanted thirty copies. “I only found out this afternoon that I could get here,” she said. She had put the date in large type so it could be read from the far side of the laundry room. The meeting was on Tuesday. By the time the hall opened again, the flyer would be useless.
There was one slot left, at 7:40. Theo had booked it to print large-type song sheets for a rehearsal. As Celia held the phone out to show Noor that it was only one page, he came through the door with the backing boards he used to carry the sheets flat. He had timed his evening around the 8:08 bus. The next bus would get him home after the person watching his daughter needed to leave. Noor could hear how little each person was asking. She could also see Theo's name on the sheet and knew how long a small job could take once somebody discovered that a file was the wrong size.
Noor kept the reservation. She turned the sheet over to the following Thursday and started to offer Celia the first opening. Celia tapped Tuesday on the flyer and slipped the phone into her coat pocket. Theo waited until she had gone before asking Noor for the heavier paper. When Noor turned the key at eight, every booked job had been done. She had been tallying completed jobs for the hall committee. She had nowhere on the sheet to put a job she'd had to turn away.
What Marta Used to Do at the Door
The following week Noor asked two regulars what usually happened when someone came without a booking. One remembered Marta making space after a late shift. The other remembered waiting while Marta printed for people who seemed to know when to ask, and he had once left after waiting half an hour. Noor had been at the machine on evenings like those. From that side of the counter she could see the pages that came out and who had to help collate them. She seldom saw who went home.
On their scheduled handover call, Marta remembered a woman who used to arrive after closing with menus for a weekend food stall. “I told her to knock on the side door,” she said. Noor asked what would happen when several people came late. Marta laughed a little and said she would put the easiest job through while someone else found their file. She could do that because she knew the machine and was able to stay. She had kept no record of who got the extra turns. She thought she had told the regulars to tell others that they could ask. Until Noor asked, she had never had to explain to anyone else how she decided.
The committee member who held the spare key had a reason for insisting on eight. Closing the print room also meant checking the restrooms and setting the alarm. When Marta stayed, she did the whole building herself. During the first month after the move, it had taken three people to cover four Thursdays. Noor could promise the same four nights the next month. She could offer no extra time at the end of them.
At the next committee meeting Theo said he'd keep using the room so long as a booking meant he could get straight to work. Celia had left the details of the meeting on two laundry room doors herself. She said she could usually get to the hall by half past seven if the hospital released her on time. Booking a week ahead meant taking a place that someone else could use if she got kept at work. “I'd rather come when I can and ask,” she said. “I'd like an evening when there is something left to ask for.” Noor laid next week’s booking sheet between them and asked which fifteen minutes they could take out of it. Someone suggested holding the first slot because it was sometimes empty. Celia pointed to six o’clock and said she would still be at work. The last slot would give her a chance, but several of the people already on the sheet had put their names there precisely because it was the only time they could make. Theo asked how late he would have to wait to find out if it was free.
A Slot They Could Give Up
The committee authorized Noor to hold back the 7:40 slot for four Thursdays. The rule would be posted beside the booking sheet. Anyone there by 7:30 without an appointment could ask for it. If more than one person asked, the place would go to the first arrival. If nobody asked by then, the volunteer on duty could give it to the first person on the standby list who was still at the hall. The 7:55 printing cutoff and eight o'clock close stayed in place. The committee asked Noor to record whether a walk-in or someone on standby used the slot, how many other walk-ins they had to turn away, and whether they closed on time. There would be a meeting after the fourth Thursday to decide what to do with the slot.
Taking one slot off the advance sheet made a difference before the trial even started. Evelyn, who usually took the last slot after visiting her husband, found the earlier times already filled. She needed to put up a set of notices before the weekend. She asked if she could have the old time just for that week. Noor showed her the new sheet and offered the first opening the following Thursday. Evelyn said that would be too late for the notices and took them to a shop instead. She came back the next week with a different job. When Noor asked what printing at the shop had cost, Evelyn told her and said she wanted the committee to count it.
Celia used the held slot the first week, this time for a follow-up meeting. She got there at 7:25 and had to wait until 7:40. The flyer came out with the right date and a margin big enough to take a strip of tape. Before she left, she checked the sign to see if there would be a slot the following Thursday. The next week two people arrived in time. One got the slot, and the other still went home without printing. On the third evening, Lee took the shift while Noor attended a parent meeting. At 7:30, nobody had asked for the held slot. The first person still present on the standby list had taken a seat near the coat hooks. Lee drew a line through the word held, wrote the person's name on the sheet and waved them in at 7:40. He logged the change and locked up at eight. Noor learned about it from the sheet when she opened the cabinet the following week.
At the end of the trial, three walk-in jobs had used the held slot. The fourth had gone to someone on standby. The sheet recorded one walk-in turned away after the slot filled, and the door log showed four on-time closures. None of those entries included Evelyn's trip to the shop. On the old report, a full slate was a good night. Noor brought the four sheets to the meeting and wrote Evelyn’s printing bill next to the full slate from the first week. The committee agreed to extend the trial for one month. For that month they would also record requests from people who could use only the late time and ask at the hall’s Saturday drop-in what an evening cutoff meant for people who rarely made it through the door. A second night would need a volunteer to close the building and money for toner. No one offered either that evening.
Noor put Lee’s sheet in the binder behind the diagram for the paper trays. His note showed that someone else could handle a quiet night without asking her what to do. She left Evelyn’s bill in the meeting folder. It belonged with the decision about what the room owed the people who used it. The group could keep the doors open, make room for people like Celia, and still have to account for the people who lost a place. That was work they could now do together, with or without the person who first opened the door.
🖨️📋🤝
Practice: The Continuity Test
Estimated time: 12 minutes
Think of one responsibility that tends to come back to you even when you have left instructions. The Continuity Test helps you look at one ordinary cycle from the position of a person stepping in. The surprise may be a decision they lack permission to make, even though the written instructions are clear.
You will leave with one dependency worth examining and a small rehearsal or private walk-through that could reveal whether the work can continue. You can use the worksheet to plan a test without asking anyone to take on the role.
Scientific Summary
An organizational routine includes what people understand to be the usual way of doing the work and what they actually do when they carry it out. Feldman and Pentland (2003) describe these aspects as connected. The usual pattern guides particular actions, and those actions can reinforce or change the pattern over time. This is a theory of how routines can be stable and capable of change. It helps explain why a written procedure and a trial run can reveal different things about a handover. It offers no estimate of how much a rehearsal would improve the chances of a successful transition.
Ostrom (2009) reviewed arrangements for governing common-pool resources such as fisheries and irrigation systems. In her account, rules fitted to local conditions and a way for affected users to take part in changing them were among the features associated with institutions that lasted. The print-room story borrows a question from this work: who can revise an allocation rule, and who gets a chance to say what it costs them? The analogy concerns the allocation of scarce staffed time. Her cases cannot tell us how many slots a small volunteer program should reserve or how to transfer a founder's role.
Tuomala et al. (2018) examined nonprofit founder transitions using tax records, a survey and interviews. Among the approaches they examined, the pairing of a continuing founder role and a successor from within the organization performed well on measures including revenue growth, successor retention and self-reported performance. Boards and founders chose arrangements under different circumstances. Those differences may help explain the results, and revenue, retention and perceptions capture different kinds of success. They give us a reason to consider what useful advice a founder could still offer and who should be able to decide without it. The print-room trial is fictional, and the Practice is an original reflection.
Bibliography
Feldman, M. S., & Pentland, B. T. (2003). Reconceptualizing organizational routines as a source of flexibility and change. Administrative Science Quarterly, 48(1), 94-118. https://doi.org/10.2307/3556620
Indiana University Ostrom Workshop. (n.d.). Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. https://www.ostrom.indiana.edu/about/ostroms-history/nobel-prize/index.html
Ostrom, E. (2009, December 8). Beyond markets and states: Polycentric governance of complex economic systems [Prize lecture]. Nobel Prize. https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf
Tuomala, J., Yeh, D., & Smith Milway, K. (2018). Making founder successions work. Stanford Social Innovation Review, 16(2), 26-33. https://doi.org/10.48558/CDVD-V285
Legal Disclaimer: The content published on Lucivara is provided for informational, educational, and reflective purposes only and is not intended to constitute medical, psychological, legal, or professional advice. Lucivara does not diagnose conditions, prescribe treatments, or provide therapeutic or professional services. Readers are encouraged to consult qualified professionals regarding any personal, medical, psychological, or legal concerns. Use of this content is at the reader’s own discretion and risk. Copyright Notice: © 2026 Lucivara. All rights reserved. This content is protected by copyright laws and is intended for individual, personal, and non-commercial use only. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published, or broadcast in any form or by any means without prior written permission from Lucivara. Acceptable Use: The content published on Lucivara is intended for individual, personal, and non-commercial use only. Readers may access, read, and engage with the content for their own reflective, educational, or informational purposes. Except for such ordinary human use, no portion of this content may be copied, reproduced, redistributed, republished, transmitted, stored, scraped, extracted, indexed, modified, translated, summarized, adapted, or incorporated into derivative works without prior written permission from Lucivara. This restriction expressly includes, without limitation, the use of Lucivara content for training, fine-tuning, prompting, testing, benchmarking, or operating artificial intelligence systems, machine learning models, automated agents, bots, or any other computational or data-driven systems, whether commercial or non-commercial. By accessing and using this site, you agree to the Lucivara Terms and Conditions.