“Our decisions provoke reactions we did not foresee.”

John D. Sterman (2002), “All models are wrong: Reflections on becoming a systems scientist,” p. 504.

🎭🧵🔄

The coats are due Friday

On Thursday evening, Mara sends the costume library a photograph of three green coats hanging on the back of a classroom door. Her youth theater group, Juniper, has added a Sunday matinee after families asked for more seats. Could she return the coats on Monday instead of Friday? She has a parent with a car on Monday and a cast that has already rehearsed in the coats.

Across town, the Lantern Players have booked those same three coats for Saturday morning. Their fitter has two hours before the actors scatter to work and family commitments. At the library, Jo and Ellis check fastenings, make minor repairs, and mark each piece ready before it goes out again. They have staffed shifts on Monday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. The calendar records when a costume is due back and who has reserved it next. A separate workroom list records when it is ready to wear.

Until now, borrowers have asked whoever is on duty for extra time. You represent the theater groups on the library committee, and the committee has authorized you to try a clearer rule over two show weekends. Existing reservations stay on the calendar. When a rule puts one at risk, the library still owes that group an answer.

Play The Ripple Effect

Estimated time 12 minutes.

Choose a lending rule and follow what happens around it. By the end, you will have traced one way a borrower’s response changes the next person’s options and identified something the committee can check before extending the trial. All people, records, and outcomes in the game are fictional.


🎭🧵🔄


What the next borrower learns

The first weekend is the easiest one to judge. The coats either stay with Juniper or reach Lantern by Saturday. The second weekend takes longer to read because people have changed what they do in anticipation of the next handoff. A coordinator puts aside a backup. Another asks for an early pickup. Both moves make sense from where those people stand, and each changes the options the next group sees.

A consequence becomes feedback when it comes back around to influence the behavior that helped create it. When uncertain handoffs prompt extra holds, those holds make the calendar look scarcer and encourage still more borrowers to reserve backups. When garments are still in the workroom at pickup, borrowers may ask to come earlier next time. The resulting pressure gives volunteers less time to have the next costume ready. Fixing the first problem is only part of a rule’s work. The committee also has to notice what the rule asks people to do repeatedly.

Think of one rule in a group you know. Who has to adjust when it changes, and what might that person do again the next time? Name one thing you could observe that would show whether the adjustment is helping. In the costume library, a calendar full of reservations tells you something different from a rack of wearable coats ready at pickup.

Scientific Summary

John D. Sterman and the return of a decision: In his 2002 prize lecture on systems science, John D. Sterman describes policy resistance as the tendency for a system’s response to undermine an intervention. His point begins with a change that seems reasonable when we consider its immediate target. Once people and organizations adjust, the same decision can produce effects that emerge later or in another part of the system. The costume-library story applies that lens to a small fictional organization, where the effect of a booking rule is felt in rehearsal rooms as well as at the lending desk.

Delay in a simulated distribution system: In Sterman’s 1989 inventory experiment, participants managed different positions in a simulated distribution chain. Their ordering decisions and the delays between orders and deliveries contributed to fluctuations in stock and backlogs. The study found that participants gave too little weight to actions already taken whose effects had yet to arrive. Time between a garment’s return and its readiness serves a similar illustrative purpose in this story. The empirical finding concerns the inventory experiment and its participants.

Consequences beyond the original aim: Sociologist Robert K. Merton (1936) examined how purposeful actions can produce consequences outside their immediate focus. The extension request starts with an extra performance, while the eventual effects appear in a fitting, a shared calendar, and a volunteer workroom. These four endings show plausible outcomes within the constraints of the fiction. A real lending library would need to observe its own returns, repairs, and unmet requests to decide which rule serves it.

Bibliography

  • Merton, R. K. (1936). The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review, 1(6), 894-904. https://doi.org/10.2307/2084615

  • Sterman, J. D. (1989). Modeling managerial behavior: Misperceptions of feedback in a dynamic decision making experiment. Management Science, 35(3), 321-339. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.35.3.321

  • Sterman, J. D. (2002). All models are wrong: Reflections on becoming a systems scientist. System Dynamics Review, 18(4), 501-531. https://doi.org/10.1002/sdr.261



Legal Disclaimer: The content published on Lucivara is provided for informational, educational, and reflective purposes only and is not intended to constitute medical, psychological, legal, or professional advice. Lucivara does not diagnose conditions, prescribe treatments, or provide therapeutic or professional services. Readers are encouraged to consult qualified professionals regarding any personal, medical, psychological, or legal concerns. Use of this content is at the reader’s own discretion and risk. Copyright Notice: © 2026 Lucivara. All rights reserved. This content is protected by copyright laws and is intended for individual, personal, and non-commercial use only. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published, or broadcast in any form or by any means without prior written permission from Lucivara. Acceptable Use: The content published on Lucivara is intended for individual, personal, and non-commercial use only. Readers may access, read, and engage with the content for their own reflective, educational, or informational purposes. Except for such ordinary human use, no portion of this content may be copied, reproduced, redistributed, republished, transmitted, stored, scraped, extracted, indexed, modified, translated, summarized, adapted, or incorporated into derivative works without prior written permission from Lucivara. This restriction expressly includes, without limitation, the use of Lucivara content for training, fine-tuning, prompting, testing, benchmarking, or operating artificial intelligence systems, machine learning models, automated agents, bots, or any other computational or data-driven systems, whether commercial or non-commercial. By accessing and using this site, you agree to the Lucivara Terms and Conditions.

Next
Next

26.324 - Build Something That Works Without You